If your players do not enjoy RuneScape you would like to run there is no point trying to force yourself to find something that works especially as you're the RS gold one doing the work for no actual reason. OSRS and 5E seem similar but they games. 5E is essentially a super hero game and OSRS games are dream adventure/dungeon crawling games. If you wish to play with a traditional fantasy game and your players want to play Marvel The Avengers no quantity of house rules or different systems can really solve it. Just find things to do with boardgames, that category or some thing, and look for a DnD group that has a similar flavor to you. Was stop my 5e group and just start running OSRS matches for people that appreciated them.

What have you been playing? Neither are extremely high, epic fantasy independently, although the Black Hack and Whitehack are both. If your players all want to play 5e, it appears appropriate to run that or have among these DM it, or find a new play group (and that I understand that the latter two are probably just not real options). Is the machine that you're using the deal breaker for them, or will be the problem more which they're looking for a more heroic fantasy feel and don't care if they're using the same system as Critical Role? Are they the sort of players that enjoy"building characters" (acquiring skills and skills by leveling up) in the video game feel? 5e appears like the way to go if that's the case. If not, seems like being less particular with specific rules and changing the sorts of adventures you move on may be adequate.

You may try to perform with something more narratively focused and crunchy. I've enjoyed what I have read of dungeon world as well. There's also the Fate platform which I have also heard great things about storyline focus too. Regrettably I do not have too much experience playing with these, because it's quite tough to get my friends to try out stuff besides DnD. He enjoyed the attention on customization and character advancement that the foci supplied. The founder, Kevin Crawford, also appears to be working on a pure dream version named Worlds Without Number as well with a similar focus system. His beta system can be tried by you. He has also got a few more systems that I believe are interesting, like Godbound where you play as demigods combating demigod degree dangers, or Scarlet Heroes which is a system designed for low player count parties to make shooting a couple of PCs in more viable.

Low Fantasy Gaming could try. Will be for perishing to make the system more pliable imho, houserule the principles. It has a Luck score and a reroll pool to give the gamers more control over the difficulty of an adventure, but the resources deplete as they resolve challenges. Exploits give the players a feeling of agency and allows them feel badass whenever they stab an eye out or decapitate somebody mid-combat.

That having been said, if they do not enjoy the high-risk style of OSRS games, then that is a tough request. It is likely for your team and you just aren't compatible. Do you think that could adopt the style that is superheroic? Imagine if it were not a system that was buy rs gold paypal wishy-washy concerning the powerlevel of their NPCs. What if you leaned in and adopted fantasy swords and sorcery's superheroic nature? 13th Age may be exactly what you're searching for; it's gonzo in its very own way and unapologetically heroic. Best of luck! I hope you can achieve a compromise.